Review: Winter White by Jen Calonita (Belles #2)

January 4, 2013 / 10 Comments / Review, Uncategorized

Winter White
Author: Jen Calonita
Publisher: Poppy
Publication date: October 9, 2012
Format: Hardcover, 368 pages
Source: Borrowed from library
My rating: 4 of 5 stars


This installment of the Belles series starts with the Monroe family on an Oprah-like TV special talking about their reactions to the news that Izzie is Bill’s daughter. Despite appearing to be taking everything in stride, inside, Mira and Izzie are both pretty distressed over their father’s lies. This, however, brings them closer together, and makes them team up to fight off the rumours, messes, and crazy of Emerald Cove.

In Winter White, the girls are getting ready for cotillion and their debut into society. Of course, their debuts are fraught with challenges. In the previous book, Mira stood up to her former best friend (aka evil beyotch), Queen Bee Savannah. As a result, Mira is a bit of an outcast at school, and she really has no friends, although she starts to get closer to scholarship kid and fellow art enthusiast Kellen. Meanwhile, Izzie is adjusting to life in EC, but still feels like an outsider. This isn’t helped by the fact that her crush Brayden doesn’t seem to want to stand up to his family and show that he wants to date her.

All of this happens in the shadow of cotillion, which includes etiquette, dancing, and other classes, but also pretty white dresses, and crazy initiation antics – all culminating in a big event with show-stopping dresses, family, and hearts on the line.


The strength of this book and series are the characterizations of Izzie and Mira, and their relationship. Everything else – the romance, the mean girls fighting – that’s all pretty stereotypical. The authenticity of the book – and what keeps me coming back – is in how Izzie and Mira learn and grow together.

The cotillion and initiation stuff was my favourite part of the book – we really got to see Izzie shine as a natural leader and as someone unafraid of taking risks. Meanwhile, I liked the fact that Mira didn’t just immediately go back to her friends or get accepted again. She had to go through a lot of trials, and she was pretty strong while facing them.

In the first Belles book, I really connected with Izzie. In this one, I enjoyed her growth, but I was also a bit annoyed by her constant feeling that she didn’t belong in EC, her immediate love for Dylan, Brayden’s rebelling sister (even though I could tell what Dylan was up to from the beginning), and her (dare I call it) whining about Brayden. For some reason, the Brayden character has never resonated with me, so I pretty much wanted her to dump him from the beginning. That said, he seemed to prove himself in the end, so maybe there’s hope for him and Izzie yet.

For me, Mira was a real star of this book. I loved how she learned more about Kellen, moved forward with her art, and learned more about who she was, but never forgot to show the kindness and generosity that she grew up with as a Southern belle. I loved how she was just as mad at Bill as Izzie was, and how they seemed to face everything together. And have I mentioned that I really like Kellen?


Frocks – Calonita peppers her books with real-life designers and fashion, which I LOVE.

OC-like parties – This is a big reason why Calonita’s writing feels like a movie or TV show to me – the  awesome, catered parties where everything falls into place!

Girl power vs. mean girls – a classic combination, it was great to see Savannah get her comeuppance a bit in this book – but also great to see how Mira and Izzie took to heart the spirit of cotillion to become strong, sassy young ladies.

The Final Word:

Belles was very much an establishing novel, but in Winter White, I really felt like Jen Calonita and her characters came into their own. Calonita has an amazing way of making every scene feel like it could be in a movie or TV show: there’s an outsider, major scandals, big parties, great fashion and some awesome family/friend moments that make it all worthwhile. If you like The O.C. or Gossip Girl, this series is definitely for you.

Have you read the Belles series or any of Calonita’s other popular books? What do you think of them – just fluff or is there something pretty awesome in her characterizations?

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Want more YA reviews and bookish fun? Get Mostly YA Lit in your inbox and be the first to get notified on new updates.

10 responses to “Review: Winter White by Jen Calonita (Belles #2)

    • Partly because I was a bit annoyed at Izzie. Partly because I only give five stars to very, VERY special books. This is a fun, light read, but it didn't impact me so much that it deserved five stars. That said, it did achieve its goal…

      I don't know. I'm pretty subjective with the star ratings. =P

  1. Belles shocked me entirely! I loved every single second of it and that is not something that I was expecting. Winter White blew me away even more than the first. Jen Calonita's Character development, World-building, writing in general is off the charts good. I can't wait for the third installment, The Grass is Greener!

  2. I haven't heard of this series, and it sounds like there are a lot of good things going on in here–especially the relationships. It's always good to see that in books, but I'm just a little skeptical of this series for some reason.

  3. I have seen this series around the blogosphere and it intrigued me b/c I'm somehow fascinated by the whole cotillion/debutante thing(but don't think I'd want to go through it).

    This series reminds me of Anna Godbersen's books. I'm in the midst of attaining all the books in her Luxe series, a kind of period Gossip Girl(which I love).

    Good writing, good character development, and setting, I'll move it up on my TBR list. Oh, and I loved The OC too.

    Thanks for your review

  4. I have been wanting to get started on this series for a while now. I read so many mixed reviews about the books, I want to find out for myself if the book really is any good or not. Great review though! 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.